For the Cure: Breast Cancer Awareness or Bank Account Awareness?

57e514ad84f3780932dff41d5c63ee2cDid you know one in eight women in the United States will develop invasive breast cancer? And that every two minutes in the United States a woman is diagnosed? Cancer is one of the most feared words in American culture. We focus a whole month to supporting one specific type of cancer. Breast cancer awareness month is an incredible way our nation unites through multiple organizations, to support a good cause. The process is extremely easy for anyone to donate and feel like their money is going to a good cause…or is it?

Susan G. Komen for the Cure is a widely known non-profit organization that supports breast cancer research. The purpose behind this organization appears to be transparent- but has it gotten to the point where it is just money hungry? Only 20% of the money raised or donated goes directly to breast cancer research. Although this is not out of the ordinary compared to other widely known non-profit organizations, it is misleading how their partnerships also support “for the cure.” Susan G. Komen partnered with KFC to create “buckets for the cure.” KFC’s diet aids to cancer cell growth and the main reason for partnering was to, “reach out to millions of woman they might not otherwise reach…” But, Breast Cancer Action claims, if you want to reach communities that are underserved, then the Susan G. Komen organization needs to reach out to the community health clinics. Clearly from this example of their partnership tactics, there are suspect business practices within the organization. The list of controversial issues that the Susan G. Komen organization has accrued over time is actually surprising considering the foundation started with a good cause in mind.

Pink-RibbonFor the better part of the last decade, the popular breast cancer charity Susan G. Komen has been racked by controversy. Things began to go awry in 2012 when they pulled support for Planned Parenthood, amid pressure from Republican lawmakers. The non-profit responded to accusations that its actions were, “anti-woman,” saying that the funds were not pulled because of ideological conflicts, but because planned parenthood was under investigation by congress. This is a questionable statement, as the corporate structure of Susan G. Komen has strong ties to pro-life entities. Among other accusations, the organization has taken heat for using donor money to sue other non-profits for infringing on their various trademarks. Notably the phrase “For the Cure,” which has been the subject of many cease-and desist orders, even when the organization had nothing to do with breast cancer. After all of the hits the company took, rather than step down, the CEO took a huge page raise.

susangkomenFollowing Susan G. Komen’s changes in grant rules, barring Planned Parenthood’s funds, supporters increased on Planned Parenthood’s side. According to Politico, Planned Parenthood’s Facebook page increased by 10,000 in a few days. Anti-Susan G. Komen for the Cure Facebook pages increased- with titles similar to “De-fund the Komen foundation.” As the news broke regarding Susan G. Komen’s course, Planned Parenthood and #PlannedParenthood started trending on social media and became a topic of interest in mainstream media. Susan G. Komen for the Cure did not convey its message well in response to the crisis. After the crisis, the Komen foundation used storytelling as a way to reconnect with the community- starting a print and television advertising campaign, “I Am Susan G. Komen“. This campaign spotlighted four-breast cancer survivors- using their stories to market Susan G. Komen for the Cure.

An important thing for organizations, especially nonprofits, to remember is their brand identity and their actions need to match up. Cognitive Dissonance is when someone experiences a feeling of tension when their beliefs do not align with their actions. This theory states that when someone experiences this inconsistency, they will do what they can to reduce this uncomfortable feeling. The Susan G. Komen organization received backlash after developing a perfume “Promise Me”, which contains toxic and hazardous chemicals. Breast Cancer Action exposed the use of Toluene, banned by the International Fragrance Association as well as Coumarin, banned by the Food and Drug Administration.

People donate to Susan G. Komen, which presents itself as a non-profit organization donating its funds to breast cancer research. When those who donate hear about Susan G. Komen partnering with organizations, which do not promote health, such as KFC, creating harmful fragrances for sale, and giving only a small amount of money to breast cancer research, cognitive dissonance occurs. They may feel uncomfortable because of the inconsistency in what the organization presents itself as doing and what it is actually doing. Those who donate will oftentimes choose to reduce this feeling by stopping their donations to the organization altogether. If a non-profit organization wants to thrive financially, they need to ensure that their actions align with how they present themselves and their original intent.

breastcancerawarenesslogo1

Reading the information on Susan G. Komen for the Cure, one might expect all nonprofit organizations follow their guidelines. Here are other foundations and organizations supporting breast cancer research and finding a cure:

It is easy to show how significant the topic of breast cancer is within the United States. There are countless statistics about the impact breast cancer makes- that would shock any reader. So, hearing that one of the most well-known organizations, whose existence is centralized around breast cancer research and finding a cure- may not be the hero it has portrayed itself to be, is concerning.

We, as the American public, have a duty to be alert to the aspects that make up our charities and nonprofit organizations, and be diligent in how we distribute our donations. As a reader, what are your opinions on Susan G. Komen for the Cure? Would you donate your time and money to this organization?

-Jonathan Callahan, Erin Fouhy, Julia George, Joseph Hines, and Sarah Suggs

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “For the Cure: Breast Cancer Awareness or Bank Account Awareness?

  1. I had no idea that the Susan G. Komen foundation did this kind of stuff! It doesn’t come as much of a surprise though. As stated in the article above, not much of the money raised by large non-profits actually goes to the cause. Many people have to work for the non-profit and they too need a paycheck. But a pay raise? That CEO needs to prioritize and adjust some morals. Millions of people are donating for the cure, not your bonus checks.

  2. This article is very interesting. I like to consider myself philanthropic and i take pride in giving to nonprofits so reading this article was extremely informative. There were great points made that make me question if I should be giving to this organization. It is disheartening to read about organizations that are dishonest or hiding behind their actions. I will be reading more into this organization and other organizations that I currently support to be sure that they align with my beliefs and values.

  3. My mom’s side of the family has been plagued so to speak by breast cancer for decades. It’s always so hard to be positive about it, but they always pull through in the end and at the moment, no one in my family is suffering from cancer and it’s been that way for a few years. Basically just being positive and trusting in the medical care that we receive can make all the difference in the world. Thanks for the interesting read.

  4. I strongly agree with the previous commentators; a significant share of charities (like the Susan G. Komen foundation) has turned into businesses that are more profit-oriented than focused on the actual cause. Oftentimes I find it difficult to determine where exactly my money is going and to directly see the impact my donation has made.
    Something I recently started noticing are statements such as “50% of the profits are donated to …” necessarily aren’t wrong, but could be misleading to many consumers who overlook the fact that only half of the company’s profits (which might only be 5% instead of 50% of the revenues) go toward a certain charity; those customers might simply divide the number they see on the price tag in half and wrongly assume a significantly higher amount is donated.
    In my opinion, charitable organizations should be more honest and transparent about the donations they receive and how that money is divided up.

  5. It’s definitely disappointing hearing about the less-than-noble actions of these organizations, but as someone before me mentioned, it isn’t all that surprising. While raising awareness is extremely important for finding cures to diseases as terrible as cancer, I feel that the goal is often somewhat lost. I recently read an article written by a breast cancer survivor who underwent mastectomy. She expressed her frustration over how “pink” Breast Cancer Awareness Month has become, asserting that the tidal wave of pink that promotes it takes away from the pain and suffering caused by the sickness. She also expressed anger over women posting pictures of themselves going “bra-less” in “support” of breast cancer, which really does not support the cause at all. To her, it is simply a reminder of the part of her body that she lost and the pain she endured in her fight. Looking at it from her point of view and reading articles such as this one makes me question whether we have somewhat lost sight of the reasons we’re raising awareness.

  6. This post is very eye-opening and I’m glad that it’s being brought to light. It’s sad to hear that only 20% of the funds raised actually go to applied research for “the cure.” Their advertising is extremely misleading, unethical, and it reminds me to stay aware of the big picture behind foundations that raise mass amounts of money like Susan Komen for The Cure. I hope they feel the recent pressure from activists and dedicate more of their raised funds to actually finding “the cure.”

  7. I would not donate to this organization. Seems they have a conflict of interest. I personally do not donate to any organizations simply for this very reason. You do not know where your hard earned money is going or if it is even helping. When I donate, I prefer to do it when I see someone’s need. I like to give in private, and hand the donation directly to the person in need. That way I know that my donation does not go in vain, but I also do not want anyone knowing what I’ve done because the gratification of knowing I helped someone in need is all I want.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s